Rearranging Main and Footer Menu

I need to move a page (pageA) from the Main Menu to the Footer Menu and another page (pageB) from the Footer to the Main Menu. I went into Page Properties and made the changes in placement for both pages. I was successful in moving pageA to the Footer Menu and pageB no longer appears on the Footer Menu. However, pageA now appears on both the Main and Footer menus and pageB does not appear in the Main Menu.
Any thoughts on how to fix this? Am I missing something?

Never mind…I did do it correctly. It simply took overnight to propagate to the website.